Supreme Court Issues Decision In Religious Freedom Case

Christian mailman Gerald Groff of Pennsylvania requested the court rule on whether the U.S. Postal Service may make him deliver parcels from Amazon on Sundays, which he observes as the Sabbath. His lawyer, Aaron Streett, argued in April that the court needed to review a decision from 50 years ago that set a standard for figuring out when companies have to make allowances for their workers’ religious practices.

In a 9-0 decision, the Supreme Court rejected a ruling from 1977 that mandated that businesses must “reasonably accommodate” an employee’s religious practices as long as doing so does not put an “undue hardship” on the company.

Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires employers to accommodate employees’ religious practices unless doing so would be an “undue hardship” for the business. A 1977 Supreme Court case, Trans World Airlines v. Hardison, said employers could deny religious accommodations to employees when they impose “more than a de minimis cost” on the business.

Streett said the court should get rid of the “de minimus” test because lower courts have used it wrongly to deny religious accommodations. Instead, he said, the court should use the plain language of Title VII, which would define “undue burden” the same way it is in other federal laws, like the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).

Back in April, postal worker unions asked the U.S. Supreme Court to consider the potential adversity that religious accommodations for some employees may have on their co-workers.

“A day off is not the special privilege of the religious. Days off, especially on the weekend, are when parents can spend the day with children who are otherwise in school, when people can spend time on the other necessities of life, and when the community enjoys a common day of rest for churchgoers and the nonreligious alike,” the American Postal Workers Union noted in a brief to the court.

Title VII mandates that employers accommodate a worker’s religious observance or practices unless it results in “undue hardship” for the business. In the 1977 case, Trans World Airlines v. Hardison, the Supreme Court defined undue hardship as anything that imposes more than a minor or “de minimis” cost on the employer.

Groff’s legal team requested that the Supreme Court overturn the Hardison precedent and mandate that companies demonstrate a “significant difficulty or expense” before refusing to grant an accommodation.

Several groups representing religions in the United States that are in the minority, including Islam, Judaism, and Hinduism, have informed the Supreme Court that the Hardison standard has unfairly impacted them and must be revised, Reuters noted in a prior story and report.

“By allowing employers to refuse to accommodate employees’ beliefs for almost any reason, Hardison forces devout employees to make an impossible daily choice between religious duty and livelihood,” said the Muslim Public Affairs Council in a brief.

James Phillips, a law professor at Chapman University in California, told Reuters that a “strong majority” or even all nine justices could side with Groff.

“This may be one of those religious liberty cases where the right and the left are actually aligned,” Phillips opined.

Groff was employed as a “rural carrier associate” in Quarryville and Holtwood, in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. As part of his job, he was required to substitute for absent career carriers, including on weekends.

In 2013, the Postal Service contracted with Amazon.com to deliver packages, which included Sunday deliveries, in an effort to remain profitable.

Related Posts

Chapter 3 – The Secret Safe in the Study

The heavy mahogany doors of the indoor pool hall swung open with a sharp echo, revealing two uniformed officers flanked by Julian’s longtime corporate attorney, Marcus Reed,…

Chapter 2 – The Confession by the Pool

Camilla stumbled backward on the wet marble tiles, clutching her injured foot as a sharp cry escaped her lips. Her burgundy evening gown clung to her ankles,…

Chapter 2 – The Frozen Accounts

Victoria clawed desperately at the slick marble ledge of the indoor pool, water cascading down her face and soaking the heavy crimson satin of her evening gown…

Chapter 1 – The Blind Billionaire’s Trap

The marble tiles beside the indoor pool of the Blackwood estate gleamed under the warm glow of the crystal chandeliers, reflecting the still, turquoise water. Damian Blackwood…

Chapter 3 – The Silver Sedan

Rain lashed against the tall bay windows of the Sterling study as the sleek silver sedan rolled to a halt just inside the wrought-iron gates. Hannah pressed…

Chapter 2 – The Basement Vault

For a long moment, the only sound inside the wood-paneled study was the sharp metallic click of steel handcuffs locking around Richard’s wrists. Evelyn sat slumped in…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *